Statement by TV presenter Solovyov about teachers. Soloviev about teachers and they about him - free community - livejournal

Yesterday I watched Vladimir Solovyov’s passage about Russian teachers.
And somehow I felt uneasy. But I decided not to write right away in order to think it over somehow.
The reaction of others was often quite harsh.

I listened and looked at it, and I somehow felt sorry for V. Solovyov. He never met any good teachers in his life.
Or maybe he simply didn’t notice them in his pride?
Maybe something in his soul is amputated?
Is there something unfinished?
After all, a smart, educated and truly intelligent person would probably be able to evaluate this topic from all sides, including not only the “thought” that all teachers are trash, drunks, rags and trash, but also in the context of the role that teachers play in life society and influence the future of Russia through the upbringing and education of each student as a citizen and Personality.
He could, even if he really came across not teachers, but trash, drunks and trash.
I could rise above my childhood grievances and think like a statesman.
Ah, no.
Didn't pull it.

There is a wonderful saying about the evolution of a human creator in terms of his attitude to culture and his predecessors, who cannot help but become teachers for him if he develops even a little. After all, the teacher comes when the student is ready. And your teachers will be the ones you deserve.

This saying goes like this:
"Me. - Me and Mozart. - Mozart and me. - Mozart."
It is obvious that V. Soloviev got stuck somewhere in the first stage. And it’s unlikely to budge.
Sadly.

As for the teachers. When I myself was a student, I also did not meet teachers with whom I would be happy.
In this sense, Solovyov is right. But to believe that the most stupid and wretched people become teachers is a very one-sided idea. And extremely poor.
At one time, I graduated from the Faculty of History as one of the best. With honors, having a "4" only in archaeological practice and foreign languages. But he ended up at school. And he worked there for 17 years. And only after that he went to work at a university, sending thousands of students into life.

Having entered the teaching profession, I set myself the task of becoming the kind of teacher I would like to learn from. And already at school I met many wonderful teachers. Of course, they were not the majority. A teacher-creator is a piece product. But they paid for his work exactly the same as the worst teachers.
And I think this is unfair. How unfair, however, is such a disregard for teachers in the country.

Now let’s try to develop what V. Solovyov said about teachers’ “scum.” After all, even in his completely unscrupulous premise there is already a problem: it follows from his words that the worst people become teachers, because the teaching profession is not prestigious and condemns the teacher to poverty. But would the worst ones become teachers if the state changed its attitude towards teachers? So, maybe the parcel should be swapped? And then it will become obvious that the worst will not become teachers if teachers are encouraged as the best.

It is a pity that V. Solovyov does not ask this question. And by the way, I wonder why?
It’s a pity that he doesn’t think about his eight children and grandchildren, who have their own teachers - “scum and drunks.”
It’s a pity that I didn’t understand all this when I worked as an astronomy teacher at school for 4 years.
It’s a pity that I didn’t remember when I said this that his dad Rudolf Meninkovsky worked as a history teacher. And although his mother, Inna Solomonovna Shapiro, worked as an art critic in the panorama “The Battle of Borodino” after university, she graduated from the Pedagogical Institute together with her father. The same one whose students the glamorous Vladimir Rudolfovich called rabble, scum and drunkenness.

As you can see, it turns out that V. Solovyov not only humiliated and insulted teachers. Not just the students of these teachers.
He humiliated and insulted his parents.
Or maybe his opinion grew out of his personal experience? From your experience communicating with parents?
Hardly.

As a result, we state the highest degree of contempt and ingratitude of V. Solovyov towards his parents, who in Soviet times strained all their connections to get their beloved Vovochka into specialized school No. 27 with in-depth study of English. At that time, it was an elite educational institution located on Kutuzovsky Prospekt in the center of Moscow, where the children of Soviet diplomats and party officials studied (today it is school No. 1232).

Well done, Vovochka, he thanked his parents in the face and in the ass.
I thanked him publicly.
All over the country.

P.S. In conclusion.
Since I’ve already pulled out something from V. Solovyov’s personal life, I’ll remind you of something else.
In 1990, astronomy teacher V. Solovyov SUDDENLY went to the United States of America, where he taught economics at the University of Huntsville, Alabama, and along the way successfully went into business. And although he returned two years later, his business in different parts of the world, including the Philippine Islands, is running. But ties with the West still remain.

This is probably why he is a member of the Business Committee of America and also heads the Association of Young Economists
By the way, then another side begins to emerge in his protest against the increased motivation of Russian teachers.
After all, if we rely on research done on the initiative of B. Gates, even a relatively small group of talented teachers can pull the education of any country out of stagnation and backwardness in a matter of years. Russia included.

Does Russia need this? Certainly. What about the West? What more? The West, like V. Solovyov, needs teachers in the Russian Federation to be rabble, drunks and scum. And they didn’t rise any higher. Then Russia will not rise either.

Of course, V. Solovyov will say that he does not think so. That he is with all his limbs for Russia and its glorious future.
But then he has little choice: either he is a stupid and narrow-minded person, not possessing strategic thinking, but only capable of thinking situationally and on emotions, or he is a big scoundrel and a liar, hiding his true intentions against Russia.

*

*
http://storm100.livejournal.com/2598391.html "Why should a teacher get a lot of drunken joy?!"

... The urgency of the issue and the genuine passion that the TV presenter put into assessing the representatives of the teaching workshop were obviously caused by the desire to support the Prime Minister, who advised a young teacher from Dagestan, dissatisfied with his salary, to go into business. The statement hit the Internet and caused a storm of indignation. Lending a shoulder to the prime minister and the leader of the ruling party during the pre-election period is a matter of conscience, honor and heroism of the TV presenter. Nothing personal - there is a consistent and unwavering defense of state interests. What, as we know, is why V. Solovyov is valuable to history. But it seems to me that in doing so he did the Prime Minister a disservice...
...
A.P. Chekhov wrote at the beginning of the last century that a poor teacher is a disgrace to the country. And Lenin’s calls to raise teachers to unattainable heights remained good wishes throughout the entire Soviet and post-Soviet period. In 2012, in accordance with the May decrees of the President, salaries for public sector employees were raised. But by now, inflation has eaten everything up, and the level of real incomes of teachers has returned to 2013. There is no time for fat here - I wish I could live...
...
Why do I, with difficulty overcoming disgust, call the TV presenter a colleague? Based on curriculum vitae found online.

The TV screen hero studied at the elite special school No. 27, where he studied a number of subjects in English, where diplomats, children and grandchildren of members of the CPSU Central Committee studied. Today this is school No. 1232 with in-depth study of the English language. Apparently, the school gave its graduates good knowledge of a foreign language, which allowed him to live in America for a number of years in the future. Why school? But not the Institute of Steel and Alloys, which he, to his credit, graduated with honors. Consequently, along with the humanities, the school was well equipped to teach mathematics and technical subjects.

Amazingly, until 1990, the TV star taught physics, mathematics and astronomy at her native school No. 27.

But finally, the time has come when V. Solovyov fully thanked his former teachers and colleagues. It couldn’t be more opportune, on the eve of the new school year, the star calls to “stop the eternal breath of love for teachers”, justifying this call, cuts the truth to the womb: “Do I remember all teachers with a kind word”? As Stanislavsky said, I believe, not everyone. What to do - it’s a mass profession, unlike the recruitment of TV presenters, when hiring teachers, there is no casting.

“Everyone has bad dreams about school.” But it depends on your luck. (I’ll note in parentheses that TV viewers shouldn’t expect sweet dreams after V. Solovyov’s nightly talk shows.)

And finally, the seasoned wit gives vent to the emotions that burst out: “Pedagogical universities are filled with all sorts of rabble that cannot get anywhere. And so they should receive as bankers, no less than Solovyov”?

Evgeny Yamburg called the TV presenter a “helpful PR man.”

The director of the capital's school No. 109, Doctor of Pedagogical Sciences, Honored Teacher of the Russian Federation and member of the public council under the Ministry of Education and Science, Evgeniy Yamburg, called the famous Russian TV presenter Vladimir Solovyov a “helpful PR man.” He earned this characteristic after his statements about teachers.

This is how the teacher reacted to Solovyov’s words spoken during a live broadcast on the VestiFM radio station, when he commented on Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev’s statement about low teachers’ salaries.

"Often intkbbee pedagogical ones are filled with all sorts of rabble that can’t get anywhere. And so they come out and go to work as teachers. […] With what drunken joy should teachers receive no less than mine? I earn money, but I don’t receive it,” Solovyov said in particular.

As a result, Yamburg wrote in the Echo of Moscow blog that with his statement “colleague Solovyov” caused “irreparable damage to the line of the party and government during the pre-election period.”

“Why do I, with difficulty overcoming disgust, call the TV presenter a colleague? Based on the biographical information found on the Internet. The hero of the TV screen studied at the elite special school No. 27 where he studied a number of subjects in English, where diplomats, children and grandchildren of members of the CPSU Central Committee studied. Today - this is school No. 1232 with in-depth study of the English language. Apparently, the school gave its graduates good knowledge of a foreign language, which allowed him to live in America for a number of years in the future. Why a school? But not the Institute of Steel and Alloys, which he He graduated with honors with honors. Consequently, along with the humanities, the school was well equipped to teach mathematics and technical subjects. Amazingly, until 1999, the TV star taught physics, mathematics and astronomy at her native school No. 27. But, finally, it came the time when V. Soloviev fully thanked his former teachers and colleagues […] Bravo, TV presenter! Having expressed this disgusting and insulting passage to more than a million people in good faith, you have finally achieved your goal. They convinced me of the existence of a fifth column in the country, which undermines the foundations of the state. One of two things: either you exposed your own baseness, or you discovered a terrible state secret. After your speech, all talk about increasing the prestige of teaching work looks like a hoax. We'll keep thinking. Low electoral bow to you for this,” writes the honored teacher.

How, on August 4, 2016, Russian Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev, speaking at the “Territory of Meanings” forum on Klyazma, suggested that teachers who are dissatisfied with low salaries should go into business. The words of the head of government caused a strong reaction from the public.

Titanium dioxide - E171 (according to international marking) - is present in many body and hair care products: shampoos, liquid and bar soap, sunscreens, toothpastes, and various medications. E171 can also be found in a lot of food products - sweets (especially caramel and dragees), white chocolate, cakes and pastries, grated...

“IF I HAD A MAGIC WAND,” or WHAT DO OUR CHILDREN REALLY CARE ABOUT?

FROM THE EDITOR Alexander Kazakevich, author of the project and editor of “However, Life!”: - In the 90s, I taught “Theory and Practice of Oratory” in the senior classes of the 1st Minsk Gymnasium. At the end of the course, I gave the students a final task - to prepare a speech on the topic: “If I were the President...” The students were required to imagine themselves as a candidate for...

Eduard-Lyubomir VOLNY: “WHY DO I NOT EAT BREAD?”

“IT TURNS OUT THIS BREAD IS NOT SO SIMPLE...” Many of you have heard: “Bread is the head of everything”, “without bread you won’t be full”... Many have the opinion that bread is a very healthy and irreplaceable food product person. But is this really so? Bread now refers to products made from cereal flour: wheat, rye, barley, oats, and so on. Most often for the production of bread...

Guardian angel

You need to get married, my dear! By the way, popular wisdom claims that a man without a woman begins to smell like a goat! - the professor said abruptly. - Valentina Petrovna, if I need your advice, I will let you know! - Andrey Vasilyevich, why are you offended like a little one! My heart hurts when I look at you! After that tr...

TAMING OF THE SHREW

Our family could be called the most ordinary and, perhaps, even happy, if not for Uncle Kazik. That is, Kazimir Vasilievich. Almost every other day he comes to us for dinner, since he lives practically nearby, a couple of houses away. My mother, his sister, is convinced that my uncle needs to get married urgently, otherwise he will be thrown into a madhouse or, in extreme cases, taken to a zoo...

TIPS FOR LIFE

“TOUCH EACH OTHER!” Unloved, unloved children grow into angry, aggressive adults. People are dying from tactile hunger. They look at each other like a wolf, grin from despair and the inability to touch, reach out and push away. Because someone somewhere said that you need to maintain decency, hung labels. You can't kiss people you don't love, you can't hug food...

UNITED GENERATION

“SCHOOL GRADUATES HAVE NEVER HEARD OF GENERAL KARBYSHEV. BUT THEY ALL KNOW WHO GENERAL VLASOV IS.”I gave an introductory lecture to my course “Television Theory” to first-year students, that is, to those who a year ago were sitting at school and taking the Unified State Exam... Having mentioned the so-called banter, which is very common on modern television, I first translated this word into literary...

“OUR MOMS FEED THEIR CHILDREN POISON, AND THEN THEY WONDER WHY THEIR CHILDREN ARE SICK ALL THE TIME”

Today, even Russian authorities admit that up to 70% of Russian deaths are caused by poor-quality food. Why has our food become of poor quality? And thanks to capitalism - market relations, which are focused on only one thing - to obtain maximum profit. Many people in the “market” reality have not only lost their shame and conscience, they have lost their minds. Our GOST standards have been lifted...

DOCTOR'S REVELATIONS: “IN ORDER TO SURVIVE, FOR YOUR CHILDREN TO SURVIVE, YOU NEED TO TURN ON YOUR BRAIN AS SOON AS POSSIBLE”

“WHEN YOU GIVE CHILDREN SUCH PRODUCTS, YOU JUST SLOWLY KILL THEM” Not long ago, by chance, I was in the Minsk oncology center and saw a mother telling a child who had undergone a course of chemotherapy: “Well, dear, you coped with the course of chemotherapy, and Now we’ll go to McDonald’s for lunch.” This outraged me so much that I decided to express everything I thought about it...

"MAKE A LITTLE NOISE..."

"Bamtz!" - and a miniature pink car of an unknown brand crashed into the weighty rear of a large black jeep. A small plump brunette jumped out of the jeep and, having examined and felt the barely noticeable dent on the bumper, tragically wrung her hands and moaned: “Oh-oh-oh-oh!” The culprit of the accident was still sitting in his car and must have been shaking with fear. The brunette narrowed her eyes...

BORIS GREENBLAT. WHAT ARE VACCINE MANUFACTURERS HIDING?

Russian naturopathic doctor, a well-known specialist in alternative methods of treating oncology, Boris Grinblat, shares with users of the Internet portal MedAlternativa.info his opinion about vaccines and vaccination THE MORE VACCINED, THE MORE EPIDEMICS Today, once again, they are trying to push through the law “On general vaccination” in the Duma. This time it sounds a little different...

CONSCIENCE - “EXTRA LOAD”?

Let conscience be your only deity. Pythagoras “CONSCIENCE IS A MARKER OF A RUSSIAN MAN” What did the sages of the past say and how did they define conscience? Here are some of the traditional definitions. Conscience is: “the action of God in man” (Fyodor Dostoevsky); “the most important decoration of a person” (Marcus Cicero); “the law of laws” (Alphonse Lamartine); "the ability of human...

“WHY WITHOUT A HAT?”

Hello, my dear, I’ve been waiting for you! You came and found me, but I was confused... Song from the movie “Tractor Drivers” Lizaveta woke up not from her husband’s snoring, to which she had already gotten used to for many years, but from bright sunlight. Sitting on the bed and feeling along the floor with her bare feet in search of slippers, Lizaveta yawned sweetly. “It’s good that today is Saturday! - she thought. - May with...

WHAT IS CONSCIENCE AND WHY SOME HAVE IT AND OTHERS DO NOT

Before a great mind I bow my head, before a great heart I bow my knees. Victor Hugo “KNOWLEDGE OF THE LAWS OF PHYSICS... DOES NOT MAKE A MAN A RAIENT BEING” Why is our life filled with injustice, suffering and pain? Why do we live so unreasonably, so lovelessly? Perhaps because our scientific knowledge is still too small and leaves much to be desired? But let's...

VLADIMIR LUZAY: “WHEN FINDING OUT MY DIAGNOSIS, THE ONCOLOGIST TOLD ME: YOU ARE NOT A RESIDENT!”

In 2013, doctors gave Vladimir Vasilyevich Luzai, a simple truck driver from Barnaul, a terrible diagnosis - stage IV pancreatic cancer with numerous metastases in the liver. However, thanks to unconventional methods of treatment, Vladimir managed to overcome the terrible disease. In issue 10 “However, life!” we talked about Vladimir Vasilyevich’s treatment method. In a...

I sometimes watch Solovyov’s programs on TV and yesterday I noticed that Sergei Mironov was not among the invited politicians on the program. It’s strange, I thought, it’s election campaign time, but the head of the party didn’t show up. Rating time, rating program - you can’t just decide not to come to television at such a time for no reason...

And then I come across interesting information on the Internet that explains this situation and which I somehow missed.

Do you already know? No? Then I'll tell you now..

It turns out that some time ago Soloviev allowed himself on the radio to call teachers rabble, scum and drunkenness.

Here you can listen to it for yourself:

Moreover, an appeal was published on the Change.org website to the Prosecutor General's Office of the Russian Federation with a request to prosecute TV presenter Vladimir Solovyov for his recent statement about teachers. The author of the petition was a resident of Murmansk, Vladimir Pokoevets, who saw notes of extremism in the words Solovyov said on Vesti FM.

Of course, everyone understands that this speech was in response to, or most likely in support of, Prime Minister Medvedev’s statements that "there is no need to compare the salaries of security forces and teachers. He says it’s not scary that the latter earn less, and an energetic teacher will find how to earn money"

No, of course, no one will accuse him of extremism, but still the situation is disgusting. And here's why I think so.

Firstly, Soloviev is a public figure who speaks throughout the country and all his words immediately begin to apply to many people. If he talks about teachers without mentioning their names, then all the teachers take it personally. Moreover, students begin to subsume ALL teachers under these definitions.

Secondly, I am quite familiar with the work of a teacher, because... my good friend has both parents who are teachers at school, and I have seen and heard a lot about what is happening there, how we have to work with modern students and modern requirements for the educational process. These requirements are often stupid and senile. There is a huge sea of ​​bureaucracy and fraud. And with all this, the salary leaves much to be desired. Yes, if you ask teachers, you can even hear fairly average and acceptable salary amounts, but believe me, taking into account the frantic demands, it does not seem big.

Of course, the salary must certainly correspond to the quality of the teacher’s work. But often it is the requirements of the Ministry of Education and the murky rules of local education officials that hinder achieving this quality. The teachers already rotate between them as best they can for several rates and additional loads, and then they present him with the fact that he is rabble and scum.

A teacher, like a military man, like a doctor, should be proud of his profession and his salary. Teachers are a profession that should be passed on almost from generation to generation along with their knowledge, approaches and skills. If all teachers are called rabble, how should he feel in this profession? Speaking about some kind of criticism of the sphere of teaching, Soloviev allowed himself to simply pour a bucket of dirt on all teachers without exception. This is all disgusting and disgusting. This is all the level of a bazaar over a bottle of beer in the kitchen, and not on the state channel.

What do you think about this case? Should teachers expect an apology?